Odd Meter

Sieges Even members: every line-up and singer, 1985 to 2008

Eleven musicians played in Sieges Even or sang on its recordings. Two of them were there from the first demo to the last show; the rest arrived with one album and often left with the next.

How the line-up changed shape

The band went through four distinct formations. The first, with Franz Herde and later Jogi Kaiser at the microphone, made the three SPV albums between 1988 and 1991. The second was the Holzwarth brothers’ own version of the band in the mid-1990s, with Wolfgang Zenk on guitar and the Keller brothers on vocals and keyboards. The third never released an album under the band’s name: the Looking-Glass-Self sessions of 1999 and 2000 with André Matos. The fourth, with Arno Menses, began as Val’Paraiso in 2003 and stayed together until the end.

What held it together was the rhythm section. Every formation had Oliver and Alex Holzwarth, and three of the four had Markus Steffen. The singers, by contrast, almost never overlapped with each other, and each one marks a clear change in the band’s sound. The band history tells the story in order; this page is the reference for who played what.

The core: Markus Steffen and the Holzwarth brothers

Markus Steffen, guitar and lyrics

Steffen founded the band’s first incarnation with Oliver Holzwarth in the early 1980s and wrote most of its lyrics. He played on the first three albums and left after a show in Wiesbaden in summer 1992. Away from the band he turned to classical guitar, released the solo album Unsheltered Places in 1999 and published a guitar book the same year. He returned for the 1999 rehearsals that led to Looking-Glass-Self and stayed until the split in 2008. Afterwards he co-founded Subsignal with Arno Menses. German references also credit him with founding a small label, Calamus Records, around 2000. More recently he gave a new interview for the booklet of the 2024 Steps reissue and wrote the liner notes for the 2024 edition of A Sense of Change. He wrote the lyrics of “Where Our Shadows Sleep”, the 2003 song that bridged Val’Paraiso and Paramount.

Oliver Holzwarth, bass

Oliver is, with his brother, the only musician on every Sieges Even record. Outside the band he had one of the longer side careers in German metal: live and session bassist for Blind Guardian from 1997, a member of Paradox in 1999, bassist of Rhapsody of Fire from 1 September 2011 to August 2014, and part of Brutal Godz after 2008.

Alex Holzwarth, drums

Alex joined his brother’s band early on and drummed on every album from Life Cycle to Playgrounds. Rhapsody of Fire dates his start with that band to a tour in 2000; he stayed until his departure was announced on 9 October 2016. He also played in Paradox and Brutal Godz, and laut.de adds a stint with Atrocity that other references do not mention.

The singers

Franz Herde, 1985 to 1991

The first voice of Sieges Even sang on the demos, on Life Cycle (1988) and on Steps (1990). German references report a short break in 1990 before the Steps sessions. He left during the recording of A Sense of Change in 1991 and, according to the same references, later gave up music. One German biography spells his surname Heide, a slip worth knowing about when looking for old interviews. Reviews of Life Cycle still single out his voice, as strange in one account and as the record’s weak point in another.

Jogi Kaiser, 1991 to 1992

Kaiser was chosen after about three months of searching, following a trial with an American singer whose name was never made public. He recorded all the vocals for A Sense of Change in three days. His time in the band ended in 1992, when that line-up came apart after Steffen left.

Greg Keller, about 1995 to 1997

Keller fronted the two Under Siege albums, Sophisticated (1995) and Uneven (1997). Both were made with the Holzwarth brothers and Wolfgang Zenk, while Steffen was away from the band.

André Matos, guest on Equinox

The Angra singer recorded four songs with Steffen and the Holzwarths for the Looking-Glass-Self promo CD Equinox: “Equinox”, “Stigmata”, “Footprints of Angels” and “The Valparaiso Dreaming”. He was busy with his own projects and never joined as a member. Two of the four songs lived on: “Stigmata” reappeared on The Art of Navigating by the Stars in 2005, and “Footprints of Angels” is listed in reference works as the title of a 2003 Val’Paraiso demo.

Arno Menses, 2003 to 2008

A Dutch musician from Rotterdam who started out as a drummer, Menses contacted Steffen by email around 2002 and recorded his first vocals for the band in January 2003. He sang under the Val’Paraiso name, then on both InsideOut studio albums and on Playgrounds. His first recordings with the band were “The Lonely Views of Condors” and “Where Our Shadows Sleep”, sung over backing tracks made about a year before. German references give his arrival as anywhere from 2002 to 2004. After the split he co-founded Subsignal with Steffen.

Guitar and keyboards beyond the core

Markus Burchert, guitar, 1985 to 1986

Burchert was the second guitarist of the autumn 1985 line-up and played on the first demo only. He has no album credits, and nothing else about his time in the band is documented.

Wolfgang Zenk, guitar, 1993 to 1997

Zenk replaced Steffen when the Holzwarths restarted the band in 1993 and is credited on both Sophisticated and Uneven. He is the only guitarist apart from Steffen who plays on a Sieges Even album. In 1999 he founded 7for4.

Börk Keller, keyboards, 1997

Greg Keller’s brother played keyboards on Uneven, the only Sieges Even studio album with a credited keyboard player as a member. A sudden hearing loss in 1997 brought the band’s activity nearly to a stop.

Sieges Even line-up timeline

Sieges Even line-up timeline, 1985 to 2008 Horizontal bars show when each of eleven musicians was part of Sieges Even. Oliver and Alex Holzwarth and Markus Steffen run from 1985, with a gap from 1998 to mid-1999 for all three and a longer gap for Steffen from 1992. Singers in order: Franz Herde to 1991, Jogi Kaiser 1991 to 1992, Greg Keller about 1995 to 1997, André Matos as a guest around 1999 and 2000, Arno Menses 2003 to 2008. Markus Burchert played guitar 1985 to 1986, Wolfgang Zenk 1993 to 1997, Börk Keller keyboards in 1997. 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2008 Franz Herde, vocals Jogi Kaiser, vocals Greg Keller, vocals André Matos, guest vocals Arno Menses, vocals Markus Steffen, guitar Markus Burchert, guitar Wolfgang Zenk, guitar Börk Keller, keyboards Oliver Holzwarth, bass Alex Holzwarth, drums vocals guitar bass, drums, keys Dashed bar: guest, not a member
Sieges Even line-up timeline, 1985 to 2008: every member by role and years in the band.

The chart starts in 1985, the first year in which the name Sieges Even is documented. Earlier years under the band’s first name are left out because their dates are not firm. Gaps in the bars mark the standstill between 1997 and 1999 and Steffen’s absence from 1992.

Embed this timeline

The timeline is free to use on other pages with the credit link included. Copy the block below into an HTML page; it loads the timeline as one image and needs no script.

<a href="https://www.siegeseven.com/members/"><img src="https://www.siegeseven.com/images/sieges-even-lineup-timeline.svg" alt="Sieges Even line-up timeline, 1985 to 2008" width="400"></a>
<p>Source: <a href="https://www.siegeseven.com/members/">Sieges Even line-up timeline, Odd Meter</a></p>

Line-ups album by album

The SPV years, 1988 to 1991

Album Vocals Guitar Bass Drums Guests
Life Cycle (1988) Franz Herde Markus Steffen Oliver Holzwarth Alex Holzwarth none
Steps (1990) Franz Herde Markus Steffen Oliver Holzwarth Alex Holzwarth none
A Sense of Change (1991) Jogi Kaiser Markus Steffen Oliver Holzwarth Alex Holzwarth Ilse Stemplinger (viola), Renate Matthias (cello), Stephane Luhmer and Thomas Hellhake (violin)

The Under Siege years, 1995 to 1997

Album Vocals Guitar Keyboards Bass Drums
Sophisticated (1995) Greg Keller Wolfgang Zenk none credited as member Oliver Holzwarth Alex Holzwarth
Uneven (1997) Greg Keller Wolfgang Zenk Börk Keller Oliver Holzwarth Alex Holzwarth

German references name Sascha Paeth as a guest keyboard player on Sophisticated.

The InsideOut years, 2005 to 2008

Album Vocals Guitar Bass Drums
The Art of Navigating by the Stars (2005) Arno Menses Markus Steffen Oliver Holzwarth Alex Holzwarth
Paramount (2007) Arno Menses Markus Steffen Oliver Holzwarth Alex Holzwarth
Playgrounds (2008, live) Arno Menses Markus Steffen Oliver Holzwarth Alex Holzwarth

The last line-up was the most stable in the band’s history: four musicians, three releases, no changes between 2004 and the end. For the full discography with tracklists, each album has its own page.

Where the members went: Subsignal and Brutal Godz

Subsignal began as a side project of Steffen and Menses. After the Sieges Even split in 2008 it became their main band, and they added Ralf Schwager and David Bertok, the latter formerly of Dreamscape. Its studio albums so far are Beautiful & Monstrous (2009), Touchstones (2011), Paraíso (2013), The Beacons of Somewhere Sometime (2015), La Muerta (2018) and A Poetry of Rain (2023). The band’s line-up has changed since, so check its own channels for the current members.

Brutal Godz brought the Holzwarth brothers together with Charly Steinhauer and Uwe Lulis, the producer of The Art of Navigating by the Stars and Playgrounds. The debut album Echoes of the Dead was announced in March 2011.

Dates that do not agree

Two members’ dates differ between published sources, and neither can be settled here.

A third point is softer. German references say that Franz Herde left briefly in 1990 and came back for Steps; no other source mentions the gap, so the timeline shows him without a break.

Questions and answers

Who were the original members of Sieges Even?

Guitarist Markus Steffen and bassist Oliver Holzwarth started the band in Munich, joined by Oliver's brother Alex on drums and singer Franz Herde. In autumn 1985 Markus Burchert played second guitar for the first demo.

How many singers did Sieges Even have?

Four full members sang lead: Franz Herde, Jogi Kaiser, Greg Keller and Arno Menses. André Matos of Angra sang on the 1999/2000 Looking-Glass-Self promo CD as a guest. The order is told in the band history.

Which members were in the last line-up?

From 2004 until the split in 2008 the band was Arno Menses (vocals), Markus Steffen (guitar), Oliver Holzwarth (bass) and Alex Holzwarth (drums). This line-up recorded The Art of Navigating by the Stars, Paramount and the live album Playgrounds.

What did the members do after Sieges Even?

Markus Steffen and Arno Menses founded Subsignal. Oliver and Alex Holzwarth formed Brutal Godz, and both played in Rhapsody of Fire: Alex from 2000 to 2016, Oliver from 2011 to 2014.