The Art of Navigating by the Stars by Sieges Even: concept album, tracklist and comeback
Eight years after their last record and thirteen after Markus Steffen's last show with them, Sieges Even came back in September 2005 with a new singer and a record numbered in sequences.
Published
| The Art of Navigating by the Stars | Details |
|---|---|
| Released | 2005, studio album |
| Label | InsideOut Music |
| Produced by | Sieges Even & Uwe Lulis |
| Line-up | Arno Menses (vocals), Markus Steffen (guitar), Oliver Holzwarth (bass), Alex Holzwarth (drums) |
| Tracks | 9 |
On The Art of Navigating by the Stars Sieges Even sound like a band that had spent its years apart listening rather than rehearsing. The album came out in September 2005 on InsideOut Music, eight years after Uneven, and it brought back the founding trio of Markus Steffen and the Holzwarth brothers with a Dutch singer, Arno Menses, on his first full album with them.
How Sieges Even got back together
The first step was small. In the summer of 1999 Steffen and Oliver and Alex Holzwarth rehearsed together for the first time in six years. The first song they wrote was “Equinox”.
They did not call the project Sieges Even at first. As Looking-Glass-Self they recorded a promo CD, Equinox, with André Matos of Angra singing four songs: “Equinox”, “Stigmata”, “Footprints of Angels” and “The Valparaiso Dreaming”. Matos was busy with his own projects and never became a member, so the search for a singer went on. Of those four songs, only “Stigmata” reached the finished album; “Equinox”, the very first piece the trio wrote together after the break, did not.
The gap years explain some of the patience in the music. Oliver Holzwarth had been working as a session and live bassist for Blind Guardian, Alex Holzwarth joined Rhapsody on drums in 2000, and Steffen had released a classical guitar album, Unsheltered Places, in 1999. None of them needed Sieges Even to make a living, and the reunion moved at the speed of people with other commitments.
Around 2002 a Dutch singer called Arno Menses, who had started out as a drummer, emailed Steffen. In January 2003 he sang “The Lonely Views of Condors” and “Where Our Shadows Sleep” over backing tracks the trio had recorded about a year earlier. The four of them took the name Val’Paraiso and played Munich’s Nachtgalerie on 29 May 2003 under it.
By the end of 2003 they were Sieges Even again. The first show under the old name was at the Headway Festival at P60 in Amstelveen on 4 April 2004, and on 28 October 2004 they played Nachtleben in Frankfurt, the first German Sieges Even concert in seven years. The band history has the full timeline.
Recording with Uwe Lulis for InsideOut
The band produced the album together with Uwe Lulis, ending the long run with Charlie Bauerfeind that had covered every record from 1990 to 1997. InsideOut Music released it in September 2005; laut.de gives the date as 23 September. The finished album runs 63:35.
One detail shapes the sound more than any production choice: there are no keyboards. After the Börk Keller experiment on Uneven, the reunion line-up went back to guitar, bass, drums and voice, and left the space open.
Concept album or song cycle?
Every song after the short intro carries a subtitle, from “The Weight (Sequence I)” to “Styx (Sequence VIII)”. That numbering invites a listener to treat the record as a concept album, and the title points the same way: stars, a lighthouse, a crossing of the Styx, the views of condors from above.
The titles do not, however, spell out a story with characters or a plot, and none is documented. The more careful reading is a song cycle held together by imagery of navigation, distance and passage. Calling it a concept album is fair as long as “concept” means a shared idea rather than a narrative. Either way, the sequence numbers ask for the album to be heard in order, and it rewards that.
The title track is the odd one out. “Navigating by the Stars” lasts 29 seconds and carries no sequence number, which makes it a frame rather than a chapter: a short way into the cycle, not part of it.
The tracklist and its eight sequences
The tracklist opens with “Navigating by the Stars”, a 29-second intro, and then gives most of its weight to the front. “The Weight (Sequence I)” is the longest piece at 10:14, followed by “The Lonely Views of Condors” at 6:14 and “Unbreakable” at 9:00. “Stigmata” (8:22) dates back to the Matos promo, and “The Lonely Views of Condors” was one of the first two songs Menses ever sang with the band.
The second half shortens and then grows again: “Blue Wide Open” is the briefest full song at 5:13, before “To the Ones Who Have Failed” (7:26), “Lighthouse” (7:42) and “Styx” (8:55) close the cycle. Read that way, the tracklist is less a collection than an arc with a slow middle and a long final approach.
The Art of Navigating by the Stars, heard today
Menses is the reason this album works. His voice is deep and mellow, closer to a rock singer than to the high metal tenors of the band’s early years, and he sings the complicated material as if it were simple. Steffen’s writing had changed too. The riffs leave more air around the voice, and without keyboards the bass and drums fill the space that a fifth player would otherwise take.
The odd metres are all still there. What has changed is that they no longer announce themselves; a bar of seven or five slips by inside a phrase that feels natural to hum. Of all the Sieges Even records, this is the one most likely to convert a listener who distrusts technical music.
For a first listen, “The Weight” is the obvious door. It is the longest piece, it opens the cycle proper, and it contains most of what the album does well in one place: patient build-up, a vocal line that stays memorable over shifting metres, and a long instrumental stretch that never turns into showing off. If that ten minutes works for you, the rest of the album will too.
It is not flawless. Sixty-three minutes is long, and the middle of the second half loses some tension before “Lighthouse” lifts it again. But it is the band’s best album, and the judgement here is not close.
How it was received
The response in 2005 was warm and, in places, ecstatic.
At laut.de, Michael Edele was delighted by the comeback and the new singer, praising songs that are catchy and complex at the same time and ending with a buy recommendation. The laut.de band page lists the album at five out of five.
Michael Dalakos wrote his The Art of Navigating by the Stars review for Metal Temple, published on 15 September 2005, and scored it 9/10 with the verdict “Almost Perfect”. He hears a technical, atmospheric and jazzy record, singles out Menses’ deep, mellow voice, and calls the album “a beacon of light”.
A later The Art of Navigating by the Stars review by Gary Hill appeared at Music Street Journal, without a score. Hill hears a band now playing mostly pure progressive rock rather than metal and rates it “one of the better discs of its kind”.
On the road, December 2005 to January 2006
After The Art of Navigating by the Stars Sieges Even took the songs to six countries. The tour opened in Greece, at the B-Live Music House in Larissa on 3 December 2005 and the Underworld in Athens a day later, went to the B2 in Moscow on 11 December, and resumed in January 2006 with dates in Amstelveen, Weert, Vosselaar, Pratteln, Aschaffenburg, Essen and Karlsruhe. The live archive lists every venue.
The Aschaffenburg show at the Colos-Saal on 11 January 2006 left the most behind: a live recording of “Unbreakable” and a video of “The Weight”. Both songs turn up again on Playgrounds, the 2008 live album, which followed the studio record Paramount of 2007.
The Art of Navigating by the Stars tracklist
- Navigating by the Stars (intro)
- The Weight (Sequence I)
- The Lonely Views of Condors (Sequence II)
- Unbreakable (Sequence III)
- Stigmata (Sequence IV)
- Blue Wide Open (Sequence V)
- To the Ones Who Have Failed (Sequence VI)
- Lighthouse (Sequence VII)
- Styx (Sequence VIII)
Questions and answers
When was The Art of Navigating by the Stars released?
In September 2005 on InsideOut Music; laut.de gives 23 September 2005. It was the band's first album since Uneven in 1997.
Who sings on the album?
Arno Menses, a Dutch singer who had started out as a drummer. He first recorded with the band in January 2003. His later work with Markus Steffen in Subsignal is covered on the members page.
Is The Art of Navigating by the Stars a concept album?
It is built like one: eight songs numbered Sequence I to VIII behind a short title intro. A storyline is not spelled out in the titles, so it is safest to call it a linked song cycle.
Are there keyboards on the album?
No. The album was made by guitar, bass, drums and voice alone, a point several reviewers noticed.