Odd Meter

Sieges Even Paramount: the 2007 album, its tracklist and an editorial review

The Paramount album 2007 credits list the same four musicians as the comeback record two years earlier. The songs take a different route: melody first, technique underneath.

Pixel-art illustration of a recording studio control room at night, with a large mixing desk, monitor speakers and a window into the dark live room
ParamountDetails
Released2007, studio album
LabelInsideOut Music
Produced bySieges Even & Kristian Kohlmannslehner
Line-upArno Menses (vocals), Markus Steffen (guitar), Oliver Holzwarth (bass), Alex Holzwarth (drums)
Tracks10

Paramount arrived in the autumn of 2007 and turned out to be the last studio album the Munich band made. The Sieges Even Paramount line-up was unchanged from 2005: Arno Menses on vocals, Markus Steffen on guitar, Oliver Holzwarth on bass and Alex Holzwarth on drums. What changed was the emphasis. Where the previous record built long, interlocking structures, the Paramount album leads with melody and lets the technique sit underneath it.

Where the Sieges Even Paramount album fits in the band’s history

By 2007 the reunion was three years old. Steffen and the Holzwarth brothers had started rehearsing again in 1999, worked through the Looking-Glass-Self project with André Matos as a guest, found Menses in 2003 and returned to the Sieges Even name at the end of that year. Their comeback, The Art of Navigating by the Stars, came out on InsideOut Music in September 2005 and was followed by a tour through Greece, Russia, the Netherlands, Belgium, Switzerland and Germany.

Paramount stayed with InsideOut. The release date depends on where you look: laut.de gives 21 September 2007, while Metal Express Radio, Power of Metal and other listings give 1 October 2007. The gap probably reflects different release dates in different territories, and both are in the autumn of 2007.

Nobody could know it at the time, but this was the end of the studio story. A live album followed in July 2008, and in September 2008 the band announced that it had split. That makes Sieges Even Paramount the closing statement of a catalogue that began with Life Cycle in 1988, and it is worth hearing with that in mind.

Production and the Val’Paraiso song

For the first time since the reunion, the band worked with a new co-producer. Kristian Kohlmannslehner’s name on the Paramount album 2007 credits replaces that of Uwe Lulis, who had co-produced the comeback; laut.de credits Kohlmannslehner with the mix as well. The result is a fuller, rounder sound than on the 2005 record, with more space given to the voice.

One song is older than the rest. “Where Our Shadows Sleep” was first recorded in 2003, when the four musicians were still calling themselves Val’Paraiso: Corny Bartels recorded and mixed that demo version at Weltraum Studios in Munich, with music credited to both Holzwarths, Menses and Steffen and lyrics by Steffen. Menses had sung it in January 2003, at his very first session with the trio, so its place on the last studio album closes a small circle.

Reading the Paramount tracklist

The Paramount tracklist has ten songs. It opens with “When Alpha and Omega Collide” and “Tidal” and closes with the title track, “Paramount”. Between them sit “Eyes Wide Open”, “Iconic”, “Where Our Shadows Sleep”, “Duende”, “Bridge to the Divine”, “Leftovers” and the longest title in the catalogue, “Mounting Castles in the Blood Red Sky”.

Two things stand out in the running order. First, there are no sequence numbers this time. The 2005 album presented its songs as Sequence I to Sequence VIII; the Paramount tracklist drops that framing and asks to be heard as a set of separate songs. Second, the album front-loads what the band evidently saw as its strongest material. When the setlist for the 2008 live album was chosen, the first two songs of the Paramount tracklist opened that record too, and “Iconic”, “Duende” and the title track joined them. Five of the ten studio songs made the live album, more than from any other Sieges Even record.

“Duende”, a Spanish word for the hard-to-name intensity in flamenco, is the title that tends to get singled out, and it is the song one reviewer at the time picked as the highlight.

Sound and songwriting: an editorial review

Paramount is the more approachable of the two reunion albums and the less surprising one. That is the short version of this review, and it is meant as a description rather than a complaint.

Menses is the centre of the record. His voice was already the main reason the 2005 album worked, and here the songs are written around it: clearer verse and chorus shapes, hooks that return, lines that sit comfortably in his range. The rhythm section still plays in odd metres and keeps shifting the accents under the vocal, but the complexity is now something to discover on the third listen rather than something that grabs on the first.

The best songs are the ones where both sides of the band meet. The opener and “Tidal” have the drive of the earlier records and the melodic directness of the new one, and the title track ends the album with a sense of scale that the shorter songs in the middle do not reach. The weaker stretch comes in the second half, where a couple of the longer pieces repeat their ideas instead of developing them.

There is also a case for hearing the Sieges Even Paramount sessions as a bridge to what came next. A year later Steffen and Menses were making music as Subsignal, and the melodic, song-first writing of this album is closer to that band than to anything the Holzwarth brothers did afterwards. That is an inference from the music rather than a documented plan, but it helps explain why the record sounds the way it does: two of the four players were already leaning in that direction.

Next to The Art of Navigating by the Stars, Paramount sounds warmer and less risky. It is a very good album that sits just below the band’s best, and it is the easiest Sieges Even record to recommend to someone who likes melodic progressive rock and has never heard the band.

A practical suggestion for a first listen: start with the opening pair, then jump to “Duende” and the closing title track before going back to the middle. Heard in that order, Sieges Even Paramount shows its range quickly, and the quieter songs make more sense once the high points are familiar. Listeners who already know the 2005 album should give it more time than they think it needs; Metal Express Radio’s remark about needing a few spins is accurate.

How it was received

The reviews of 2007 range from three stars to near-perfect scores, and most of the disagreement is about the same thing: whether the turn towards melody was a gain or a loss.

At laut.de, Michael Edele welcomes the shift. He writes that melody and song structure now come before technique and praises Menses’ performance as a standout; the review runs under the headline “Progressive Rock mit tollen Melodien”. On the laut.de band page, Paramount carries the full five points.

Frank Jaeger at Metal Express Radio, writing on 1 October 2007, gives it 9.5/10. He finds it not quite as strong as The Art of Navigating by the Stars and says it needs a few spins, but concludes that “Paramount gets close enough to warrant being bought instantly”.

Kenn Jensen at the Danish site Power of Metal, on 19 September 2007, scores it 92. He hears a softer, more melodic album that still ranks among the year’s best progressive metal, and writes that “The musicians are in a league of their own”.

Joe Geesin at Get Ready to Rock is cooler, at three out of five stars. He hears light progressive rock with AOR touches that should suit fans of Asia and Yes, and feels the focus on songs blunts the album’s impact, while calling it “A strong and pleasant album that should do well.”

At the Dutch site Festivalinfo, Cosmo Vloedbeld, on 25 September 2007, praises the playing but finds the album flat as a whole, with the longer tracks wearing thin. “Duende” is his highlight.

The October 2007 tour

The band took the new songs to Europe in October 2007. The Paramount album 2007 tour opened at the Metropolis in Munich on 5 October and included ProgPower Europe in Baarlo on 7 October, the Markthalle in Hamburg, the Colos-Saal in Aschaffenburg, Rock City in Uster near Zurich and the Reigen in Vienna, with the Spirit of 66 in Verviers on 16 October as the last date listed. The full list is in the live archive, and the people on stage are on the members page.

Nine months after that last listed show, Playgrounds appeared: a live album on which half the songs come from Paramount.

Paramount tracklist

  1. When Alpha and Omega Collide
  2. Tidal
  3. Eyes Wide Open
  4. Iconic
  5. Where Our Shadows Sleep
  6. Duende
  7. Bridge to the Divine
  8. Leftovers
  9. Mounting Castles in the Blood Red Sky
  10. Paramount

Questions and answers

When was Paramount released?

In the autumn of 2007 on InsideOut Music. laut.de gives 21 September 2007; several reviews and other listings give 1 October 2007, which may reflect different release dates in different countries.

Who produced Paramount?

The band co-produced it with Kristian Kohlmannslehner, who is also credited with the mix.

Is Paramount the last Sieges Even studio album?

Yes. It was followed only by the live album Playgrounds in July 2008, and the band announced its split on 20 September 2008.

Is "Where Our Shadows Sleep" a new song?

No. It goes back to 2003, when the line-up recorded it as a demo under the name Val'Paraiso. It was one of the first two songs Arno Menses sang with the band.