A Sense of Change (1991): a new voice and a string quartet
The singer left halfway through the sessions, and the replacement sang the whole album in three days. A Sense of Change still became the most melodic thing Sieges Even had recorded.
Published
| A Sense of Change | Details |
|---|---|
| Released | 1991, studio album |
| Label | Steamhammer / SPV |
| Produced by | Charlie Bauerfeind & Sieges Even |
| Line-up | Jogi Kaiser (vocals), Markus Steffen (guitar), Oliver Holzwarth (bass), Alex Holzwarth (drums), Ilse Stemplinger (viola (session)), Renate Matthias (cello (session)), Stephane Luhmer (violin (session)), Thomas Hellhake (violin (session)) |
| Tracks | 8 |
A singer leaves mid-session
The third Sieges Even album was recorded in 1991, again with Charlie Bauerfeind producing alongside the band, as he had on Steps. Partway through the sessions Franz Herde left. He had sung on both earlier records, and the band now had backing tracks and no voice.
What followed took months. Some of the material was tried with a female singer from the USA whose name was never made public. After about three months the choice fell on Jogi Kaiser, and Kaiser then recorded every vocal on the album in three days. That compressed timetable is worth keeping in mind when listening: these are not parts worked out over weeks of pre-production.
The studio, according to a 2024 review of the reissue, was AHA Studio in Munich. The band later described the album as one of the first recordings done fully digitally, in DDD.
Strings and a softer palette
Next to Kaiser, the most obvious new element is the string quartet: Ilse Stemplinger on viola, Renate Matthias on cello, Stephane Luhmer and Thomas Hellhake on violin. They open the record on “Prelude: Ode to Sisyphus” and return as colour rather than as a constant layer.
The album appeared on Steamhammer/SPV, the last of three for that label. laut.de gives 1992 as the year; nearly everything else, including the recording timeline, gives 1991.
How it sounds now
This is the record on which Sieges Even stopped sounding like a metal band that played progressively and started sounding like a progressive band that sometimes played metal. Kaiser’s voice is smoother and more melodic than Herde’s, and Steffen’s writing leans into that, with clearer verses and choruses than anything on the first two albums. The odd metres are still there, but they now sit under the song rather than on top of it.
It holds up better than its two predecessors, mostly because the songs are allowed to breathe. “Change of Seasons” and “These Empty Places” are the two that best show the balance. The weakest stretch is the middle, where “Dimensions” and “Prime” sound more like studies than finished pieces.
The circumstances of the vocal recording are audible in a way that is easy to miss at first. Kaiser was singing over arrangements written for someone else, and some of the lines feel placed on top of the music rather than grown with it. That this rarely gets in the way is the real surprise of the album. A singer given three days to learn and record a full progressive album could easily have sounded careful; Kaiser mostly sounds at ease.
How it was received
RevelationZ published a review by Steen on 16 January 2014, with the one-word verdict “Thoughtful” and no score. It treats the album as close to a masterpiece, varied and melancholic, singles out “Change of Seasons” and “These Empty Places”, and opens on the observation that “Every Sieges Even album has been different from the last”.
The Forgotten Scroll reviewed the 2024 reissue on 10 October 2024. Mamercus describes a turn from progressive metal towards progressive and art rock, carried by a more melodic singer, and welcomes the reissue of what he calls a “phenomenal groundbreaking album”.
The 2024 reissue
Golden Core and ZYX brought the album back on 20 September 2024, remastered, on CD and on LP. It was the album’s first vinyl pressing, and Markus Steffen wrote the liner notes.
After the album
The line-up did not last. In the summer of 1992 Sieges Even played Wiesbaden, and after that show Markus Steffen left for personal reasons. The Holzwarth brothers carried on with new musicians on Sophisticated in 1995. The songs, though, came back: when the reunited band chose a setlist for the live album Playgrounds in 2008, “The Waking Hours” and “These Empty Places” were the only two picks from before 2005.
A Sense of Change tracklist
- Prelude: Ode to Sisyphus
- The Waking Hours
- Behind Closed Doors
- Change of Seasons
- Dimensions
- Prime
- Epigram for the Last Straw
- These Empty Places
Questions and answers
Who sings on A Sense of Change?
Jogi Kaiser. Franz Herde, the singer on the first two albums, left during the sessions, and Kaiser recorded all the vocals in three days. More on the line-up changes on the members page.
Who plays the strings?
A session quartet: Ilse Stemplinger (viola), Renate Matthias (cello), and Stephane Luhmer and Thomas Hellhake (violin).
Was A Sense of Change released in 1991 or 1992?
1991 in almost every reference. laut.de lists it under 1992.
Is there a vinyl edition?
Since 20 September 2024. Golden Core and ZYX reissued the album remastered on CD and, for the first time, on LP, with liner notes by Markus Steffen.