Uneven (1997): the last Sieges Even album before the long break
Uneven is the only Sieges Even album with a keyboard player in the line-up, and for eight years it looked like the band's last word.
Published
| Uneven | Details |
|---|---|
| Released | 1997, studio album |
| Label | Under Siege |
| Produced by | Charlie Bauerfeind & Sieges Even |
| Line-up | Greg Keller (vocals), Wolfgang Zenk (guitar), Börk Keller (keyboards), Oliver Holzwarth (bass), Alex Holzwarth (drums) |
| Tracks | 8 |
Eight songs, 44 minutes and 17 seconds, and one more musician than usual. Uneven appeared in 1997 on Under Siege Records, the same label as Sophisticated two years before, with Semaphore also named as a label on some listings. Charlie Bauerfeind produced it with the band, his fourth and final album with Sieges Even.
Five players for once
The line-up is the Sophisticated quartet plus a keyboard player. Greg Keller sang, Wolfgang Zenk played guitar, Oliver and Alex Holzwarth stayed on bass and drums, and Greg’s brother Börk Keller joined on keys. For a band whose sound had always been carried by guitar, bass and drums alone, this was a real change in texture. It was also a change in how the band could arrange: chords and pads could now hold a passage together while the guitar played against it, something a four-piece has to fake or leave out. The members page lists every line-up in order.
How the record is built
Where Sophisticated packed eleven short songs into one album, Uneven goes back to longer forms without returning to the epic scale of Steps. The running order broadly grows as it goes. “Disrespectfully Yours” opens in under four minutes; “What If?”, “Trainsong”, “Rise and Shine”, “Scratches in the Rind” and “Different Pace” sit between four and a half and six; “What’s Up God?” passes six; and “Love Is as Warm as Tears” closes the album at 7:17.
That gradual lengthening is the album’s quiet structural idea. The first half is lean and song-led; the second half gives the keyboards and the rhythm section more room.
The titles have more personality than on Sophisticated, too. “Disrespectfully Yours”, “What’s Up God?” and “Scratches in the Rind” sound like a band willing to be wry, and “Trainsong” promises something more relaxed than anything on the earlier records. At 44 minutes the album is barely longer than Life Cycle, the debut from nine years before, but it spends that time very differently.
An assessment
The title is honest. Uneven is uneven, and it seems to know it. The keyboards are the main reason to seek it out: Börk Keller uses them to fill out the harmony under Zenk’s guitar rather than to compete with it, and on the longer tracks the extra layer gives the songs a depth that Sophisticated lacked.
The shorter songs at the front are less distinctive. They are competent, sometimes catchy, and largely interchangeable with the material on the previous album. Then “What’s Up God?” and the closer arrive, and the record finally sounds like a band with a direction again.
Greg Keller also sounds more settled here than on his first album with the band. Two records in, the vocal lines fit the music more naturally, and the songs seem written with his voice in mind rather than adapted to it.
It is hard to hear Uneven without knowing what came after it. Taken on its own terms, it is the strongest of the two mid-1990s albums and the better entry point for anyone curious about that period. For a broader sense of how German progressive metal developed around it, see the progressive metal bands guide.
Silence, then a rehearsal in 1999
After Uneven, activity slowed to a stop. By 1999 both Holzwarth brothers had joined Paradox, and Oliver had a second job on stage and in the studio with Blind Guardian. Steffen had spent the decade on classical guitar.
The three founders met in a rehearsal room again in the summer of 1999, six years after they had last played together, and came out of it with a new song, “Equinox”. It led to a project named Looking-Glass-Self, a promo CD with André Matos of Angra as guest singer, and eventually to Arno Menses and the reunion album The Art of Navigating by the Stars, released in 2005. Neither Keller sang or played on it.
Uneven tracklist
- Disrespectfully Yours
- What If?
- Trainsong
- Rise and Shine
- Scratches in the Rind
- Different Pace
- What's Up God?
- Love Is as Warm as Tears
Questions and answers
How long is Uneven?
44:17 across eight tracks. The shortest is the opener, "Disrespectfully Yours" (3:50); the longest is the closer, "Love Is as Warm as Tears" (7:17).
Who played keyboards on Uneven?
Börk Keller, the brother of singer Greg Keller. He is not credited on any other Sieges Even album.
What happened to Sieges Even after Uneven?
The band went quiet. The Holzwarth brothers joined Paradox in 1999, and in the summer of that year they began rehearsing with Markus Steffen again, which led to The Art of Navigating by the Stars in 2005. The history page covers the gap.