Odd Meter

Playgrounds (2008): the live album that closed the Sieges Even story

Ten songs, one singer, and nothing from before 1991: Playgrounds documents the reunion line-up on stage, and two months after it appeared the band was gone.

PlaygroundsDetails
Released2008, live album
LabelInsideOut Music
Produced byUwe Lulis
Line-upArno Menses (vocals), Markus Steffen (guitar), Oliver Holzwarth (bass), Alex Holzwarth (drums)
Tracks10

A live record at the end of the line

Sieges Even released one live album, and it was also the last thing they released. Playgrounds came out in July 2008 on InsideOut Music and SPV; laut.de dates it to 25 July, other listings to 28 or 29 July. Uwe Lulis, who had co-produced the 2005 comeback, is named as producer in the laut.de review.

The line-up is the reunion quartet that had been together since 2003: Arno Menses singing, Markus Steffen on guitar, Oliver and Alex Holzwarth on bass and drums. By the time the album appeared, they had behind them a tour in December 2005 and January 2006 and the October 2007 run for Paramount. The live archive collects the dates.

What the setlist says

The ten songs tell their own story about how the band saw itself in 2008. Half the record comes from Paramount: “When Alpha and Omega Collide” and “Tidal” open it in the same order as on the studio album, and “Iconic”, “Duende” and “Paramount” follow later. Three songs come from The Art of Navigating by the Stars: “Unbreakable”, “The Lonely Views of Condors” and “The Weight”, which closes the album.

The remaining two are the surprise. “The Waking Hours” and “These Empty Places” both come from A Sense of Change, the 1991 album sung by Jogi Kaiser. Nothing from Life Cycle or Steps made the cut, and nothing from the two mid-1990s albums made without Steffen.

That last omission is easy to explain: those records belonged to a different line-up. The absence of the first two albums is harder to read, and two of the three reviews below picked up on it.

How it plays

Playgrounds sounds like a band that knew its material thoroughly. The performances stay close to the studio versions, and the sound is clear enough that all four instruments stay distinct even in the densest passages. The two songs from 1991 fit in better than might be expected, which says something about how far ahead of its time A Sense of Change was in this band’s catalogue.

The limitation is the same thing seen from the other side. There are few liberties taken with the arrangements, few extended passages, little sense of a particular night. As a document of what the reunion line-up sounded like on stage it is reliable; as a live album that adds something to the studio records it is modest. For newcomers it works as a compact introduction to the later band.

It also fills a practical gap. The reunion line-up only made two studio albums, and Playgrounds is the one place where songs from both sit next to two from the early 1990s, sung by the same voice. Heard that way, it is less a concert souvenir than a short best-of chosen by the band itself.

How it was received

laut.de praised the polished, transparent sound but found the setlist too thin on older classics. Michael Edele held back the top mark this time, writing “Die Höchstnote muss dieses Mal jedoch ausbleiben”; the laut.de band page lists four out of five.

Klaus Reckert at Gaesteliste.de, on 25 July 2008, wrote that the album sounds exactly like the band’s concerts, and also noted how heavily it leans on recent material.

At Metal Temple, Nikos Nezeritis gave it 7/10 on 8 August 2008. He found the songs faithful to their studio versions with no surprises, which makes the album most useful to newcomers, and suggested a DVD would have served the band better.

Two months later

On 20 September 2008 Sieges Even announced their split “due to internal differences”. Blabbermouth, reporting it, added that no further information was available. There has been no reunion since.

The members went in two directions. Steffen and Menses continued with Subsignal, which had begun as their side project; its first album, Beautiful & Monstrous, appeared in 2009. The Holzwarth brothers formed Brutal Godz, whose debut Echoes of the Dead was announced in March 2011, and both played in Rhapsody of Fire, where Alex had been the drummer since 2000 and Oliver took over the bass in 2011. The whole arc, from the first Munich demos to that September announcement, is on the band history page.

Playgrounds tracklist

  1. When Alpha and Omega Collide
  2. Tidal
  3. Unbreakable
  4. The Waking Hours
  5. Iconic
  6. These Empty Places
  7. Duende
  8. Paramount
  9. The Lonely Views of Condors
  10. The Weight

Questions and answers

When was Playgrounds released?

In July 2008 on InsideOut Music and SPV. laut.de gives 25 July 2008; other listings give 28 or 29 July.

Which albums does the setlist draw on?

Five songs come from Paramount, three from The Art of Navigating by the Stars and two from A Sense of Change.

Did Sieges Even release anything after Playgrounds?

No. The split was announced on 20 September 2008, and no reunion has followed. Markus Steffen and Arno Menses continued in Subsignal; see the members page.